Election reading : The Song of Jianghu Cruising 选举第一书选 ：笑傲江湖
Filed under Food for thoughts, Philosophy
Tags: Malaysia 2008 general election jokes book politics anim
For all Asian, the best story about politics is none other than famous Hong Kong writer Cha Liang Yong 查良鏞(Pen name : Jing Yong 金庸) book : The Song of Jianghu Cruising or The Smiling Proud Wanderer (mandarin ping yin : Xiao Au Jiang Hu 笑傲江湖)
Jing yong has wrote opinion about the main character with and refer him as a solitary or recluse mentioned inside Confucious “LunYu”(论语）.
Solitary or recluse are pretty unique in Chinese society philosophy. In Confucianism, a solitary are wise man refuse to serve the authority. However, Zhuangzi philosophy view “solitary” in differently : a wise man that will do his duty to safeguard the welfare of society, but will not hesitate to quit when he done is job, or when the situation does not permit him to perform.
The definition of solitary is merely one contradiction between Confucianism vs ZhuangZi philosophy.
JingYong has wrote an amazing food of though : is it worthwhile for one to scarifies important things in their life to achieve something, whether it is for money, power, avenging ,etc?
Dong Fong Bu Bai castrate himself to learn Kuifabaodian Swordplay (another name for PekChe Swordplay) in order to seize power to become leader of the Sun & Moon party.
Yat Bu Qun castrate himself to learn PekChe Swordplay to become the leader of 5 mountains alliances.
Ling Peng Zi castrate himself to learn PekChe Swordplay to avenge the death of his parent.
Yu Chang Hai son is killed by Ling Peng Zi when he plot the plan to snatch PekChe Swordplay scripts from Ling Peng Zi family.
In story of ZhuangZi, there is a story talk about well being of living vs materialistic gain.
The Kingdom Chu want to hire ZhuangZi as prime minister. The king representative seek out for ZhuangZi and notify the news.
ZhuangZi ask,”I know Chu has a big turtle dead for thousands of years. The turtle shell has been put on the temple and honor by Chu king for century. Let me ask you a question, as the turtle, do you prefer to be death shell and honor in the temple or alive and dip its tail in the mud?”
The representative answer,”The turtle definitely prefer to be alive and dip its tail in the mud”.
ZhuangZi, “Please go back to your king, I prefer dip my tail in the mud”.
Many people though ZhuangZi don’t like to be officer. In fact, it is partially true, it is not because ZhuangZi don’t want to be the prime minister, but according to history, that Chu kingdom are in the midst of self-destruction. All the king during the warring state period are not hesitate to execute their minister for no reason.
Dong Fong Bu Bai, Yat Bu Qun has little hesitate to gain and castrated themselves to gain the power of PekChe swordplay. Even they know it means they will lost the manhood forever.
While for Ling Peng Zi, although he did successfully avenge the death of his parent, but he pay a hefty price and his family trait are ended because he castrated himself.
Besides the powerful PekChe swordplay, JingYong also touch about the issue of unity.
Another tyrant in the book, Jo Leng Chan, has plot a plan to merge 5 different faction together and make himself the leader for the new union. To do that, Jo Leng Chan has plan undercover over other factions, plot fake enemy attack, killing other faction leader, and many dirty tricks and propaganda to fake the requirement of a strong united faction from others factions(besides his own faction ).
When writing the story in the 60’s, JingYong has a clear mind about the problem of “unity”. Always, the problem is not the unity itself, but the process. Many country and government, calling for “unity”, “harmony”, but with a price of suppressing dissident voices and even pay with blood. When the leader gain the absolute power from “unity”, they will shed even more blood.
This is similar to the ZhuangZi philosophy to warn people the danger of corruption of authority.
Where to get the book
For mandarin version, Chinese bookstore has the stock. English version are difficult to find locally, since Malaysia English reader rarely know Jing Yong,
However, you can get read the online translation version of Smiling Proud Wanderer. The translation has
金庸的《笑傲江湖》 ， 虽然完书于六十年代， 可是书中所说的事物， 历久犹新。 如果说《动物庄园》 是西方不朽的文学作品， 那末《笑傲江湖》就是东方唯一可以和《动物庄园》相交的文学作品。
虽然金庸在《笑傲江湖》的后记用了孔子的论语， 对书中角色约为解说， 但是如果仔细阅读《笑傲江湖》全书， 就会发现《笑傲江湖》是有很深入的《庄子》和道家哲学的见解。
【葵花宝典】和【辟邪剑法】名称不同， 可是性质一样 ： 它们威力其他， 练成剑法的人都近乎天下无敌。 可是练的人却要付出很大的代价， 就是引刀自宫， 割掉小弟弟才能开始练功。 金庸这别出心裁的故事， 其实就是道家哲学中，对于人们重物而轻生的最大指责。 杨朱曾经被孟子片面抨击【一毛不拔】， 作为道家自私自利的例子。 在【列子，杨朱】 却说明孟子其实在栽赃杨朱, 故意误导人们对道家的看法来提升儒家学说。
禽子问杨朱：如果要拔你身上一根毛， 去帮助世人， 你愿意吗？
杨朱答道 ：世间的事， 并非用一根毛可以解决的。
禽子对说杨朱 ： “我只是假定一根毛可以解决问题， 你会做吗？”， 杨朱不理睬禽子。
禽子见到孟孙阳， 对他说事情的起因。 盂孙阳说，“你根本不了解杨朱的意思。 我问你， 如果在你皮肤上纹身给你一万金， 你会做吗？”
禽子答 ： “我可以”。
孟孙阳又问 ： “如果把你手臂的一节折断，然后把一国的地方送给你， 你会答应吗？”。 禽子沉默很长的一段时间，没有回答。 孟孙阳说 ： “一根毛是比肌肤微小， 而肌肤又比手臂微小。 可是一根毛积起来成了肌肤, 而肌肤的集成就成了手臂的一节， 一根毛虽然只是其中的万分之一部分， 以此类推，一根毛那里可以轻视不呢？”
東方不敗,林平之,岳不群， 一个为了成为教主， 一个要报仇， 而一个为了五嶽劍派霸主的权力， 虽然目标不一样， 可是全部为了达到的目的， 不惜自宫练剑。 个人重物轻生的态度非常明显。 而余沧海也因为搜括【辟邪剑法】， 无意中让自己的儿子送命， 最后还死在林平之的手上。 任我行为了一统江湖而耗费心力而逝世； 五嶽劍派各众，被岳不群用剑法引诱入洞搏斗至死，都让人见识了【为物轻生】的唏嘘。
除了【为物轻生】， 《笑傲江湖》 也让人注意到了过程(process) 比目的 （achievement) 还重要的问题。 许多国家喜欢提倡团结这个口号， 可是为了达到团结的目的， 过程却是让人惊心触目。 有权人士为了【团结】这目的不择手段，而付诸于谎言，威逼利诱，甚至于暴力。
左冷禅把徒弟放入华山派的卧底， 利用华山派剑宗挑战岳不群来探他的虚实； 利用和魔教人士交往的借口屠杀劉正風全家来削弱衡山派； 叫人假扮日月神教的人偷袭恒山派； 收买泰山派的人来个窝里反； 种种手段，表面上说要合拼对抗魔教，事实上却只是为了称霸江湖，甚至于去打江山称王。
当然也别忘了那些“千秋万载，一统江湖”的口号。 这和许多独裁和半桶水民主国家的口号，没有多大的分别。 对此， 如果大家还记得马哈迪时代的”效忠“运动的话， 大概是会心一笑吧。